Saturday, October 13, 2007

Middle Class Part 10: Corporate CEO Pay and Tax Shelters

Usually I include a long prologue introducing the material, qualifying it before presenting it; this time I'll get right to it. The sub-topic in this ultimate of blog diatribes- corporate tax shelters and corporate CEO pay. I will summarize and connect the dots next time, after all of the evidence has been presented:

1) Terry Semel, Yahoo Inc.’s head received $71.7 million in total compensation despite the fact that the internet company he heads is getting killed by Google in both profit growth and stock performance, two big indicators of a company’s financial health. (his salary actually only totaled $250k, the other $71.4 million came from stock grants and stock options. I'm a novice in the economics, tax attorney business-I sure hope that all of the stock grant and option money is taxable at some point or another at the graduated rate, considering the scandalous amounts of money CEOs are receiving- if the answer is no, "why" would probably not be my only question);

2) according to a Congressional Research Service report, CEOs make 179 times, on average, as a typical worker, up from 90 to 1 in 1994. “By contrast, median household income edged up only 8.6 percent from 1990 to 2005, according to U.S. census data.”

3) Said one managing director for investment banking who advises corporations through the bank’s Activist Defense Group: “ ‘Compensation is only excessive when it exceeds industry norms and the stock performance has been underwhelming.’ ” Ah, wrong, compensation is excessive for corporate CEOs when corporations are tight-fisted about letting the rest of their employees, who may also aid in a company’s overall performance in on a bit of the action. Justifying CEO pay on the basis of the “well, that’s capitalism” defense, especially when CEO salaries are coupled with the tax shelter information I will provide below is perfectly criminal. Besides, plenty of the mismanagement at major companies, causing stock prices and profit margins to dwindle is directly attributable to a CEO’s incompetence. (After finding out that you unwittingly hired an asthmatic harmonica player for all of your prison blues music needs, wouldn’t you stop providing him with less than the golden parachute, improve his health care by giving him free albuterol without a co-pay and ask him to learn how to play anything but a wind instrument?);

4) Two CEOs who left Home Depot Inc. and Pfizer Inc. “left battered companies with golden parachutes worth $210 million and nearly $200 million respectively.” Ah, when I fail, I get a 2.0% raise, when I succeed 2.3% and that is often based on my immediate supervisor's objectivity, or lack thereof. The argument that the CEOs are paid a lot of money because there are only a certain number of qualified people willing and able who can run companies is as idiotic as using outdated marshmallows to make rice krispy bars- it just doesn't make sense to trot out that opinion, or the congealed marshmallows. By the way, if you are in need of some cement mixing compound, rice krispy bars made with expired marshmallows is a way to save a trip to Home Depot to purchase the cement mix. This concoction, because you aren’t gifted stock options worth a couple million dollars for failing so miserably, is an affordable alternative. People, thought to be qualified enough to run a company are just as likely to run a company into the ground as make it viable. Ironically, running a corporation into the ground is what PLENTY of CEOs are capable of, which is just what happens when a parachute doesn't open up- whether that parachute is golden or not. (Proof of Pfizer’s CEO failure: http://www.fiercebiotech.com/story/ceo-mckinnell-gets-the-boot-as-pfizer-struggles/2006-07-31; if you want proof of HD’s CEO failure, if you have the patience to suffer through these blog columns- you will be able to figure out how to obtain through a search engine. Incidentally, I read that one of the reasons for the HD failure was because of consumers and contractors complaints about their customer service- which can be tied to the types and number of employees a company in the service industry decides to hire- meaning, employees can have an effect on a company’s well-being);

5) “CEO pay isn’t set by markets, [said Richard Finlay, founder of the The Centre for Corporate & Public Governance] . . . Instead, it is ‘determined by a small clique of like-minded directors, most of whom are themselves past and current CEOs with a vested interest in perpetuating a failed, but to them, remarkably generous system.’ ” (And I already know all about those who favor the business industry's right to police themselves and for the most part, I believe that, just not in this case. They learned that approach, and are allowed to practice it, from/by the government . . . but have I already used the analogy about the pedaphile running the day-care? Damn, should’ve saved that one);

6) Warren Buffet, a man well-known for his generosity where his pocket book is concerned said, “ ‘too often, executive compensation in the U.S. is ridiculously out of line with performance.’ ” (objectivity and altruism- is there a pill form for that?)

7) For more from this article about shareholders having more of a voice in determining the pay of CEOs, shareholder activism, compensation committees, and SEC disclosure rules requiring companies to explain the reasoning behind executive pay packages see- http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/19079624- which is where I gained the material from all six of the elements listed above.

8) My, to be fair moment comes to you courtesy of Rachel Zupek’s CareerBuilder.com article: “Will a Bigger Salary Make You Happier” http://www.careerbuilder.ca/CA/JobSeeker/CareerAdvice/ViewArticle.aspx?articleid=246 Really, anyone knows that acquiring wealth doesn’t bring happiness and we all joke that we’d like to have such a problem. Do some research on lottery winners and find out what they have to deal with once they turn in their winning ticket- but with middle class income salaries, I'm concerned with people who earn their money. Any freshman majoring in Sociology could have written it. I’m not equating money to happiness, I’m equating it, via the ability to afford a college education, to the increased ability to enjoy life, to be content. Again, I’m primarily concerned with the well-being of the middle class- and I haven’t even included all of the political and economic reasons for that concern.

Now, we've come to the tax shelter portion of the program:
Courtesy of: http://www.corpwatch.org/article.php?id=13884- “Having Their Cake and Eating it Too – The Great Corporate Tax Break” (2006)
9) “Companies as large as Boeing, Halliburton, Morgan Stanley, Pepsi, Citigroup and Xerox are either incorporated in tax havens or have a large number of subsidiaries there. This allows them to under-report their profits for the purposes of paying tax whilst at the same time benefiting from taxpayer money through government contracts.”

10) People might ask- now, what percentage of missing taxes, misallocated tax money/government waste would you suppose could be gathered, and what could you do with the money once rescued from corporate tax havens, government waste programs, and legislative directed pork barrel spending if an independent panel of objective, engaged, honest citizens were employed to meander through the government’s ledgers (state and federal) looking for cash to fund more worthwhile ventures? Well, things such as focusing on crime reduction, minimizing health care premiums, etc.- to wit: “ ‘the amount of money that is lost to tax havens, from developing countries alone, every year is six times the amount that would be required to fund universal primary education,’ ” according to Guy Ryder, the General Secretary of the International Confederation of Free Trade Unions. (Though, I would probably wish to separate the government’s involvement in education some, but that is gloriously outside the scope of this topic);

11) Also from Ryder, “ ‘At a time when business is taking up more share of productivity gains than ever, when companies are reporting higher profits than ever and when employer-sponsored social safety nets [note: I think they mean the rising costs of health care passed onto employees] are being eroded, would it not be only fair to ask corporations to put something back into the public spending purse? After all, it is only due to government investment in infrastructure and education that these companies have been able to stay competitive.' ” I’ll get into this later, but the next paragraph from this article mentions that “there is no correlation between generous corporate tax breaks and an increase in investment,” which is something that directly contradicts everything I read in Friedman, and much of what Adam Smith wrote on the topic. As there is no study indicated from which the writer has gleaned his data, I cannot confirm or deny the veracity, but a war of facts is at any time likely to get us nowhere without a little objectivity. Suffice to say, a conservative might boil their argument down to Gordon Ghekko's/Michael Douglass' line from Wall Street “Greed . . . is good,” but that won’t win them this pissing contest. Ghekko was right about the USA being a malfunctioning company, but greed isn’t what will save it, but taxing the ever living hell out of all corporations won’t either; taxing them more, as they can afford it, will.

12) “if we eliminated corporate welfare, that alone would allow for the income tax to be reduced by nearly ½ for those making between $27,682 and $55,225 . . . this would benefit small businesses by eliminating the anticompetitive nature of corporate welfare spending.” (Again, I cannot corroborate this, as I don’t have the time to spend hours researching every sub sub-topic which produces a fork in the road, but a panel of reasonably paid, objective people who are only slightly qualified to do so- sure could, if it could fund programs to slow illegal immigration before completely stopping it, by instituting a national identification card program for starters. (Government oversight committees and Senate or House Permanent Subcommittees on Investigations taking on the task of holding politicians accountable for misuse of funds, some of which is already being performed . . . well, that would be like having a pedaphile run the . . . ah, huh);

13) “The much-derided Political Action Committees (PACs) were created by the 1974 federal election reform law, with the intention of reducing political corruption.” (You have two chances to figure out why this hasn’t happened- and one of them should probably involve the words "tax shelters", or a short phrase about politicians being in bed with businesses. I've heard our conservative talk-show host friend Bob Davis ask callers putting forth this argument to prove it, c'mon . . . is their a tonic to slow the progression of naivete? This happens PLENTY, and if you are looking for proof and its fairly overrated nature- see my first two offerings (parts 1 and 2) on this overall topic);

That’s enough for now, but I simply have far too much material and so I will include more on this specific sub-topic next time. Some may wonder- how many entries to this diatribe might there be? I have no idea, but I lit up another conservative talk-show host (Jason Lewis- FM 100.3 in MN) last week by telling him that conservatives were pretty good at putting social issues in a vacuum. Republicans tend not to see how one social issue might connect to another, and I mentioned that he must not have fared too well as a child in dot-to-dot drills in his ScoobyDoo exercise and coloring book. The reason I mentioned this is that he had been attempting to make a connection between the smoking ban and people who continually eat food that is unhealthy for them. See, smoking was banned because it is a public nuisance to non-smokers and has been directly tied to second-hand smoke inhalation deaths, despite what others might say. This may be disproven, as science may state next decade that the human lung has the capacity to funnel second-hand smoke to a gland that disposes of it with no ill effect to those not actually smoking the cigarette. But until that happens and until a fat person who eats a big mac and fries five meals a day is found to have the ability to breath cholesterol into my arteries, the comparison is a ludicrous one. The concern should have been restricted to the government's right to legislate against freedoms- how everyone else's health insurance rates might rise because of other people's obesity is the proper place to start.

The short answer to when will I be done with this topic- I don't know, just as I don't know how many cocktail weenies I'll consume at any of a variety of holiday parties this winter. After I've consumed as many as possible, I will breathe the aroma of barbecue sauce in the direction of anyone who might get easily offended- conservative or liberal and see who has the stronger arteries, testing my hypothesis about the correlation between excessive cholesterol levels and the clogging of arteries. See, just to, ahhhh . . . connect the dots, these last two paragraphs were included because at some point I will have to connect the dots between CEO pay, tax shelters for corporations and the overall major topic of this blog. I'm demonstrating my ability to do that.

From Last time- I neglected to include-
Another government waste article to check out from Business Week’s Howard Gleckman: “The Shameful Seven” (doing a search for- “angora goats mohair military coats business week” should get you to the right place. I have plenty of other examples of government waste, but I am taking for granted that you don’t need me to include all of them to take my meaning- ok, just one more- http://www.heritage.org/Research/Budget/wm839-list.cfm

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

Middle Class Part 9: Government Waste of Our Tax Money

Playing Favorites: I’m not in favor of the government further inclining the progressive/graduated tax bracket (which means taking more tax money from the rich simply because they make more money), for reasons that Milton Friedman and Adam Smith, via P.J. O’Rourke, have outlined somewhat adequately- that the whole nation of accidentally altruistic capitalists might help the poor more if they aren’t forced to. I’m also not in favor of the government raising any of a variety of taxes- income, property, gas, sales (for vehicles or for Snickers bars or anything in between), after bridges collapse, or for any of a variety of reasons that for the sake of brevity, (go figure) I will forego the listing of. Nope, until the government is made to discontinue their mis-allocation of funds they already currently receive, not one penny more should be handed over to the government. One possible exception- tax money derived from corporations which I will get to next time.

The blame game: I haven’t tracked the party most responsible for the below list, but keep in mind, since Franklin Roosevelt (democrat) was president, there have been six republican presidents (Eisenhower, Nixon, Ford, Reagan, Bush I and Bush II), encompasing 36 presidential years since 1933, (through Bush IIs reign- 2008) the year in which New Deal programs began to be initiated and I haven't seen them be all that successful in reducing the number government programs. The New Deal programs are thought to have provided the momentum to grow the government beyond the measure that republicans say they are comfortable with. Certainly, a president cannot be held solely responsible for the government’s spending. I have no idea how often any of them employed the veto on bills passed by Congress, that directly or indirectly grew the government. In short, I don’t know that government (number of programs or spending) shrank under any president- republican or democrat, or under any Congress, however it was constituted- (ie. with a democratic or republican majority). And in terms of the national debt, no three “peace-time” presidents grew the national debt more than the last three republicans. (http://zfacts.com/p/318.html). An economics major, or the ghostly apparitions of Friedman or Smith may be able to convince me that comparing excessive taxation to national debt increases under republican presidents is not an apt comparison, but it doesn’t look good and it would look better if a liberal were the one objectively shooting down the significance of any apparent connection- I am not a liberal- or an animal for that matter (my second Seinfeld reference). I might rather be re-circumcized by a blind Chilean witch doctor using dull coconut shards than listen to the average conservative condescendingly qualify everything a republican politician does, while excusing it. Stop with the “yeah but” that each side essentially employs; forget about “real” money, and “adjusted for inflation” increases using decimals and percentages, etc. All of that is cockamamy fine line rhetoric and both sides are masters at it. Enough! In short, democrats and republicans are both to blame; voters cannot be blamed for a reason I will get into next time.

“It is one thing to show a man that he is in an error, and another to put him in possession of truth.” – John Locke

What a Waste: Below is a listing of all of the ways various components of the Federal Government have wasted our tax money. If this money were re-allocated for the building of bridges, border control, rooting out gang-related criminal activity, and put into a fund to pay an independent agency (not necessarily populated with beurocrats) to discover even more excessive misappropriations of our tax money- taxes would not need to be raised. There is no possible justification the reptiles/politicians who “represent” us might provide for the fiscal atrocities listed below. The list is hardly complete- these are just the most aggregious things I could find in a few hours of looking. I haven’t included pork barrel earmarks allocating $350k to the research of the autistic Canadian Whoot Owl, or $1 million to protect a gnat species from extinction, or things like alloting $225k for a mansion in Kansas courtesy of republican Congressman Todd Tiahrt*- in short, things that might be fiscally irresponsible or morally questionable expenditures, things on the state and federal level, things with relatively little justification, compared to say, hm, enforcing a border or two and adequately inspecting and replacing bridges.

Note: the source of the first (10) instances below is courtesy of (The Heritage Foundation, April 4, 2005- http://www.heritage.org/research/budget/bg1840.cfm) The primary source material (footnotes to articles, reports, and audits), which is where the Heritage Foundation gleaned their findings, can all be found within the heritage.org document I cite above:

1) the Pentagon paid nearly $1 million to ship two 19-cent washers to an Army base in Texas. Over six years, C&D Distributors in Lexington, S.C., run by two sisters, collected $20.5 million in fraudulent shipping charges from the Pentagon. (oh, so many sources for this one- try usatoday.com or do a google search on pertinent terms)

2) between ‘97-‘03, the Defense Department purchased, and then left unused, approximately 270,000 commercial airline tickets at a total cost of $100 million. They never bothered to get a refund for these fully refundable tickets.

3) “Unreconciled Transactions Affecting the Change in Net Position.” This is the unabridged title of a report derived from the “Department of the Treasury’s 2003 Financial Report of the United States Government.” The report explains that the unreconciled transaction totaled $24.5 billion in 2003. This is more disgusting than learning that the average person has between 5 and 22 pounds of fecal matter in their digestive tract . . . but just barely.

4) an audit of Department of Agriculture employee purchases over six months, estimated that 15 percent of a sample of 300 employees abused their government credit cards to the tune of $5.8 million. Taxpayer-funded purchases included Ozzy Osbourne concert tickets, tattoos, lingerie, bartender school tuition, car payments and cash advances. 1,549 USDA credit cards belonging to people who no longer worked at the Dept. of Agriculture were still in circulation (as of 4/4/05).

5) Defense Department (Air Force and Navy personnel) over an 18-month period used government-funded credit cards for entertainment events, gambling, cruises, exotic dance clubs and prostitutes- charging a total of nearly $300k.

6) “Medicare pays as much as eight times what other federal agencies pay for the same drugs and medical supplies.” In 2002 the Department of Veterans Affairs paid $1.02 for 1,000 ml of saline solution and Medicare paid $8.68; the DVA paid $127.72 for a standard wheelchair and Medicare paid $570.68; the DVA paid $762.10 and Medicare $1754.55 for a semi-electric hospital bed.

7) in 2002, the Department of Education loaned $55,000 to three students who didn’t exist in order for them to attend a college that also did not exist.

8) “The Army Corps of Engineers spends $5 billion annually constructing dams and other water projects . . . the Corps has repeatedly been accused of deliberately manipulating its economic studies to justify unworthy projects” because it is in charge of “evaluating the science and economics of each proposed water project.” (That is kind of like a pedaphile running the daycare).

9) the earned income tax credit (EITC), which can be refunded to 19 million low-income families was overpayed by an IRS estimated $8.5 to $9.9.

10) Department of Redundancy Department- the government allows for 342 economic development programs, 130 programs serving the disabled, and 23 agencies providing aid to the former Soviet republics. (No wonder the unemployment rate is so low).

11) the “Special Inspector General for Iraqi Reconstruction concluded that the Coalition Provisional Authority” (those responsible for rebuilding Iraq) “could not track over $8 billion it had transferred to Iraqi ministries.” Numerous Special Inspector General reports have documented a range of problems- including “excessive reliance on sole source contracts” (ie. relying on one contracting company- any chance the Coalition was getting the best bid if they only approach one contracting company?), “instances of contractor fraud.” Just another thing I would regulate- contractors. Has anyone had an enjoyable experience, regardless of how much money it cost? Seriously, root canal work performed through one’s own nostrils by a dentist with tourettes would be more enjoyable. The press release quoted from above can be found on any state senator’s website.

12) Minnesota State Senator Norm Coleman (the chairman aof the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations) in his annual report addressed findings of government waste: “the subcommittee identified $12 billion in government waste, fraud, and abuse;” “more than 27,000 military contractors owed roughly $3 billion in unpaid taxes-while continuing to do business as usual with the federal government.” Just a thought, how about we hire an independent state and federal money tracking firm and pay them half as much as we pay politicians to police themselves- (see my concluding remark to #8 above). Maybe I could begin by hiring a well-dressed arthropod (think Jiminy Cricket) to whisper into the ears of legislators and governmental consigliares (an Italian word, often associated with the mob; this person serves the role of say chief of staff, or vice president in the current administration to guys like Al Capone, John Gotti, or President Bush) to have a conscience when the politicians figure on misspending our money. Hell, most of the politicians are wooden, so you can see how I could make the connection. And yes, I am making a comparison between plenty of current and former politicians to the mafia, at least in terms of a fiscal abuse of power where it translates to societal irresponsibility (ie. excessive taxation)

13) a United States Coast Guard project known as Deepwater paid $24 billion for water and air craft. $100 million of that was intended to upgrade cutter watercraft, “lengthen them to 123 feet, and extend their service lives [but] has produced 8 cracking hulks that are now tied up in Baltimore, unable to return to service and waiting for the scrap heap” . . . courtesy of two of the world’s largest defense contractors, Lockheed Martin and Northrop Grumman. (see- http://www.tscm.com/deepwaterdoodoo for further information about the project from this April 18, 2007 press release).

14) go to: www.taxpayersleague.org/pdf/2006PigletBook.pdf for a listing of 2006 Minnesota state budgetary misallocations according to taxpayersleague.org. Some of what they deem as unnecessary state expenditures could be argued by one person or another as justifiable allocations- but just a couple of examples of what you will find contained in their report: “A new $776 million Twins Stadium to be paid for with a Hennepin County sales tax increase (approved by state legislators with no voter referendum)” and “Becoming an Outdoorswoman – $45,000- A series of workshops and classes for women on hunting, fishing and other activities, including ‘dutch oven cooking’ and ‘food dehydrating.’ These types of classes are already being provided by the private sector.”

*- http://www.pbs.org/nbr/site/onair/transcripts/070706b

Keep in mind: we, the voters, are to blame for the excessive taxation and the misuse of the money excessively taxated . . . (just kidding- there is no such word as taxated; and that first part about the voter being blamed for how much we are taxed and where it is spent- yeah, only complete morons and who think they have their finger on the rash of problems constituting our social ills think that- some of us think that there is an ointment for that rash). Can you imagine what we could do in this country with the money misspent by the federal and state governments . . . run by republicans and democrats? “Ahhh,” you might say, “it is the voter’s fault we are in this predicament.” Only to a point.

Next time: Corporate Welfare, tax shelters and the “consent of the governed.”

Monday, September 3, 2007

Middle Class Part 8: The Price of Necessary Costs

"Education is not a problem. Education is an opportunity." -Lyndon B. Johnson

(But I'd add- with the price of tuition, education has been made a problem because of the lack of an opportunity).


Long overdue Note of Clarification: For the remainder of the columns I will be referring to “necessary costs” as- unavoidable purchases/expenditures nearly all citizens would like to be able to afford in order to maintain or grow their futures- their own as well as their children’s, not monetarily but more from an enjoyment standpoint. If we learned anything from Whitney Houston- it would be “that children are our future,” and also to not be pressured into a cocaine habit toward which our husbands likely steered us out of some marital peer-pressure directive. Ok, that was two things. At any rate- “necessary costs” include, but are not limited to- vehicles in good working condition; homes with yards that are suitable environments for the raising of children; paying for swimming lessons, baseball camp, dance recitals; the financing of weddings for said children, and funerals for our parents who once thought of us as the future; home repairs; contributions to a retirement account, repayment of our student loans, infrequent vacations, medical care, child-care, etc. Most of what I mean by the words- “necessary costs” is pretty much contained in point (e) from my May 23rd post. One more thing- I am using “necessary” in terms of what is valued by any citizen who intends to have a satisfying life, and not struggling to obtain fundamental necessary things such as food, clothing, shelter, etc.

First and Foremost: The first and most important necessary cost is a college degree. I am focusing on that one because I see that it is going to be increasingly problematic for future generations of middle class kids to be able to afford a college education, given the price-tag on a college degree and how much it will cost them (in terms of earnings- something I addressed last time) should they be unable to afford to finance one. A college education is the necessary cost that will most determine how obtainable all of the other necessary costs will be. Hopefully, people are, by now, willing to accept these truths:

1) by and large, people with a college degree, earn more money throughout their working careers than those without one (see data from last time);

2) the costs of college tuition are growing each year; (see, letter (c) from my May 23rd installment. If you want the politician’s stance on this go to: http://www.senate.gov/~govt-aff/020900_pressb.htm which addresses the fact that a 2008 republican presidential candidate, Fred Thompson, and a former democratic vice-presidential candidate (turned independent) Joseph Lieberman, went before the Governmental Affairs Committee in 2000 to discuss their concerns about rising tuition costs. Now, politicians feign concern about any number of issues all the time, and it is not until they propose legitimate bills, risk losing elections for taking potentially unpopular stances, and alienate constituencies, in the name of what is right for the country, that I will begin to take them seriously. They know that an appeal to the 80% of the country that considers themselves middle class is a sound political move. At least the two suits mentioned above appeared to be interested in- "bridging an economic divide" concerning the ability to afford a college education, to paraphrase a Lieberman line from the linked press release above. Also, Norm Coleman, Minnesota’s senior senator, writes in his annual report, that “federal Pell Grants . . . no longer yield the same purchasing power as in the past due to rising tuition costs.” I wonder what our favorite radio personality with a proof fixation, would have to say about his national (Thompson) and local (Coleman) republican heroes proving my point;

3) we should feel sorry for hamsters suffering from progeria- a premature aging disease- (just making sure you are awake);

4) if states across the country don’t spend some tax money on education, tuition rates will continue to rise. I'd propose to empower an investigating committee, without infringing on an industry's right to make a profit, should be convened to look into the businesses I suspect are positively fleecing the citizens of the country where necessary cost goods and services are being exchanged for money. The old adage goes- "a fool and his money are soon parted," and I'd add: never so quickly as when a blind eye is cast upon the dubious transaction by the government that could have prevented it. I could include several quotes concerning the waste of time and money usually attributed to a committee and rightfully so (but I'll just choose one: "Committee- a group of men who individually can do nothing but as a group decide that nothing can be done."- Fred Allen) There is a definite basis for monitoring certain industries, as well as justified concern about wasted money spent on the salaries of committees filled with self-righteous highbrows. I think the findings of an objective committee looking into some of the practices and dealings of free market businesses is worth the relative pittance paid to members of the committee in terms of salary compared to how much money they'll save the nation of consumers when they discover what passes for "fair market value prices" (ie. price-gauging). Think of one thing- how many millions CEOs obtain in buyouts for mismanaging a company, while workers are paid a trifling salary. I hate to defer my facts for a later post, but I'll get to that as well- trust me, or fear it- you decide.

Regulation I: I’m well aware of the attempt, and failure, of some form of regulating the private market business industries due to price-fixing issues, among other reasons, when the National Recovery Administration was developed by Roosevelt in the mid 1930s. But unfortunately, the government has seemed to take a laissez faire (hands-off) approach to certain free-market industries rather than to adopt some regulating principles. Big business, and the oil and insurance industries, to name just a few, are positively bleeding the public of necessary cost money that cripples their ability to provide a better life for their children. Perhaps there is some minimal form of regulation in these areas. If there is regulation, given the greed and incompetence of the people in charge of regulating, and the roadblocks that place limits on the types of regulation, any existing regulation is less productive than teaching a hoofless unicorn, who suffers from short-term memory loss how to make a MacGyver bomb to get back at the rhinocerous who insulted the size of the unicorn's horn.

Regulation II: Republicans think that regulating capitalism is akin to socialism, a common republican outcry if you check their greed in any manner. The fact that I have read some Milton Friedman and some Adam Smith (I said some, hell Wealth of Nations is about 900 pages long), and agree that the government should not regulate self-interest in terms of commerce, at least not entirely, proves I'm no socialist. I'm in favor of some, not carte blanche, regulation. But regulating the free market may be necessary in some measure as it is better than the lean toward feudalism that has been coming for some time without regulation- given any number of facts I could cite, and probably will, or have, concerning wage increases negatively impacting the public's purchasing power. Again, more on this in subsequent posts. I've read Friedman and Smith enough to know what kind of slippery slope I'm treading- talking of regulating the free market when the two distinguished economists I just mentioned wrote extensively of the dangers of handcuffing/limiting the freedom of private businesses. While I don't agree with either of them on everything, I'm mostly willing to agree with them on that- I'm sure they're relieved. Anti-trust laws do not even come into play here- the reason: why would two or more businesses in the same industry illegally formalize a pact in order to coerce the public into paying more for less, when many industries are so successful at exorbitantly raising prices to no ill effect, in the form of the public's hesitancy in purchasing such services, (ie. college tuition, toys made in China,** youth hockey, etc) without a formal coercive pact.

5) pay increases from companies, for job performance, even for jobs obtained as a direct result of having a degree in the first place, are not matching the annual rise of college tuition and other necessary costs. The more it costs to attend college, means more money will be borrowed, which means paying more, for longer, on interest. This means there won’t be as much money, or any, for other necessary costs;
An October 2005 Seattle Times article speaks to this point- “Double Whammy: Prices Up, Wages Lagging”: http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/nationworld/2002562268_econ15.html- I’d welcome an opposing, objective viewpoint that would state this has substantially changed in the past two years. Not all news contained in the article is bad, and I recognize this- as prices on hotel rooms, computers, and clothing declined (at least as of two years ago) while housing, gas prices and medical care costs rose. Unfortunately, I would classify that as anything but a wash- the prices on the latter three items have risen at rates much faster, and cost far more than the former three.

a) Having a home, if you have kids is far more necessary than paying for a hotel room, which happens most often when you are on vacation, which true middle class people with young kids can’t afford to do logistically or economically anyway. Businessmen charge the hotel room rate to their place of employment.

b) Gas prices rise and fall for undemonstrated reasons, when the price of a barrel of oil is relatively cheap, and when the number of barrels in stock is fairly high, and when the effects of national or international natural disasters- (earthquakes, hurricanes, etc.) on the price of oil, have not been demonstrated, such as when they occur in countries that don't deliver us any oil.
Concerning a supposed gas use excess by certain people: The fact that gas prices rise for absolutely no reason is especially damaging to the wallet of a person who has to drive more than 30 miles to work, perhaps because people’s employment options can sometimes be limited. If a business was closer to home and paid them a competitive wage, there are few reasons why they wouldn’t have pursued a position in that company. To be fair, gas prices, when you consider inflation, haven’t been terrible, but the gas companies should standardize the prices. There are few reasons for the market to be as volatile as it has been. The reason that the oil industry hasn't been checked in terms of their price fluctuations is because the politicians stand to gain for being kind to oil magnates, and vice versa- the situation is the epitome of political ass-kissing. One note- if we had the ultimate capitalistic economy shouldn't the government allow equal footing to other industries that may provide other viable energy resources, that may be renewable, cheaper, and make us less dependent on other countries? Shouldn't capitalism reign in all industries, even the ones that provide perhaps the best case studies for corruption. In short, should we only have government sponsored capitalism. We complain about the greed of the oil companies, and rightly so, when a gallon of gas goes up to $3 if they do not have a good reason for such a hike. The fact that it is Memorial Day weekend is not a suitable reason. We're not bartering for a shell necklace in Barbados, we're buying a tank of gas in America; the price needn't be determined by the whim of the seller whose level of greed is based on the gullible nature or perceived desperation of the buyer. You don't walk into a convenience store and pay 65 cents for a Milky Way one week, 40 cents the next and 89 cents the next week.

Fill 'er up: So, one cannot say that everyone is overusing gas, plenty of people have to or they would be forced to work at jobs that may not pay as well. And would you be the one telling people with a commute that long where to work and where to live? So, they could tell you where they would like you to work and live? Didn't think so. Those who argue that a lot of gas money is wasted while people sit in traffic must themselves listen to the argument that there would be less traffic if the immigration issue were addressed (see my last posting- date)- which is a much bigger issue than the price of gas, the length of a commute, etc. Again, if you can't see the connection between immigration and the amount of traffic, the length (in time) of the average commute, then you aren't looking hard enough; but, maybe I'm looking too hard. I'll do some leg work to see if there may be a connection between the increase in wasted time spent in traffic jams and the immigration problem, but if you are like me, you probably have never found a good reason why Americans prefered the German version of 99 Luft Balloons over the English version).
6) Homes- the prices on houses are declining, unlike the interest rates.
I'm not stating that mortgage protection legislation is the answer, because if someone was talked into buying a home, outside of their means, with a large payment and a teaser interest rate, and they charge a lot of unnecessary items on their credit cards, they deserve their fate- for they are wasting their own money (something I'll nail the government for next time- course the government is wasting someone else's money). I'm saying, home buyers accepted the arm/flexible/teaser/sub-prime interest rate because they couldn't afford a house without having done so (assuming of course they don't buy things they don't need). Will this type of necessary cost issue resolve itself when middle class kids are looking to own a home 20-25 years from now? Not likely. (See the Associated Press article- "House moves to expand Mortgage Protection" http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20837318)

6) if all of the above are true, even the one about the hamster, (#5 is as much about minimal wage increases as about the constant increases in price of "necessary costs"), then can’t we conclude that only the rich will be able to fund a college education, because they won’t go into debt, or into as much debt, paying back the interest derived from such a hefty loan, BECAUSE THEY WON’T HAVE TO TAKE OUT A LOAN to begin with? Rhetorical question. Again, keeping this in perspective, see my second post for what I'm thinking is the most important concern- the kids. Shouldn't we be concerned about the continual rise of all types of necessary costs and the effects of excessive taxation (the latter point I haven't much addressed as yet).

7) if #6 computes, won’t that mean that only rich people will be populating the higher paying jobs, further perpetuating the pay scale issue that has been proven in #1 because middle class kids won't be able to afford an education? As I've demonstrated, I'm far from a genius, but I wrote the preceding before having read Milton Friedman's thoughts on the subject: PLENTY of individuals are restricted from being trained in the more expensive professional programs, and are part of a " 'non-competing' group sheltered from competition by the unavailability of the necessary capital." (Capitalism and Freedom: University of Chicago Press, pg. 107)

Look for it: Anyone can find these things out for themselves: I could spend five blogs revealing my findings based on results obtained from any number of Google searches, but I suspect that reasonable middle class people living through the weekly management of their finances already know how difficult it is to juggle money and justify expenditures over which they have little control, besides that would be redundant and I can be redundant without too much effort.

To wit: a June 26, 2007- msn.com article-
http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/SavingandDebt/SaveMoney/MiddleClassLivingOnTheEdge.aspx
Google it: Key a search into google- “average cost of a middle class home”* (replace home with wedding, with funeral, with health care, with just about anything you can think of). Try "vacation" for example. Say you wanted to head to DisneyWorld (they raised their prices to $71, up from $67 for admission to one park for one day- that's a 6% increase). Start looking for a new furnace, or a roofing company, and see where all the money you expected to start saving after you've paid off a vehicle will be going for the next year, when the furnace breaks down or the roof leaks, or regrettably, a child is diagnosed with an illness where the insurance company doesn't cover all of the treatments or the medications. Further, comparing the rising prices on necessary costs, like the aforementioned, among others, to what things cost 10 and 30 years ago, and whether the prices on necessary costs have risen at a rate that meets or beats inflation is also not necessary, because we know things are more expensive. If someone claims this to not be true, that would be more disgusting to me than sitting next to a mouth-breather who has eaten half a bag of corn nuts with a warm milk chaser. Oh, and go tell them to wake up, because they're dreaming.

*- Obviously, the housing market is pretty good right now if you haven't a house to sell, so first-time buyers are feeling pretty good, but those who must sell in order to buy are not.
**- A recent Associated Press article "Safe Toys to Cost More - But not this Christmas" (September 13, 2007), indicates that toys will cost 10% more because of improved testing standards stemming from the lead-tainted toy uproar which led to the recall of more than 3 million toys.
Next time: So far, I have addressed the problem of the rising prices of necessary cost goods or services as being outside of the price range of middle class people in the future as they pertain to the amount of money to be made depending on one’s level of education. Next up- Government waste- which will lead me into the topic of excessive taxation. Ah, why would we- rich, poor, or middle class want to be taxed more, if PLENTY of the money we're already giving the beurocrats is being spent unwisely? Rhetorical question.

Friday, August 24, 2007

Middle Class Part 7: Education as it Equates to Earnings

Prior to my vacation this summer I was getting into a very necessary aspect of this topic- how much the government takes in in taxes, how much it spends, and broadly, in which areas- military, social aid, national debt, etc. Before proceeding further I am going to take a step back and tie the extent of one’s education to one’s expected financial earnings. Hopefully this is a task that will be more delicately done than accepting the, ahem- crappy job of narrator of a documentary about how effectively hippos release previously stored deposits of dung from the river bottom in order to discourage wildebeasts from crossing the said body of water in their territory. I could make an analogy between that endeavor and following the herd to the voting booth to choose between one pathetic democratic or republican candidate or another- but I'll abstain.

Don’t sound the alarm: In a June 17, 2007 Star Tribune editorial concerning Minnesota’s higher education needs, it was revealed that Minnesotans spent $7.31 in tax dollars per every $1000 of personal income, which ranked Minnesota 25th in the nation. Well, one state has to be in the middle of the road, a couple states have to be the best at something, and some have to be the worst- you can’t be the best in the nation at everything. And if we’re in the middle of the pack on education spending, then we may be the best-ranked state in terms of livability, and maybe trending toward the worst in terms of the number of gangs per 1000 people. I’m just trying to be reasonable. If you are alarmed by everything you read, you are dismissed, even if you bring plenty of alleged facts into the discussion that others do not want to hear. I am officially on guard anytime I read something from the Star-Tribune because they are not very objective politically, to say the least. They’d support an illegal alien, homosexual tree-frog who spear-heads a lobbyist group called the Bowel Movement, whose major desire is to be allowed to evacuate on city walkways because a limited study indicated that feces on sidewalks could environmentally improve the earth beneath the cement. Not wanting to be proven wrong is many people’s greatest fear, which is not quite as strange as a puppet’s strange attraction for a certain bird species, but it is close. Gonzo’s (from The Muppet Show) romantic proclivity for chickens is just slightly more disturbing than Bert’s (from Sesame Street) unhealthy co-dependence on pigeons- (poor Ernie). Inexplicable- for death awaits no matter how encouraged you might be about the voracity of your beliefs. Being wrong is alarming, but some are more concerned about that than the death that awaits after a voting career where they've done nothing but continue to justify the political good-old-boys.

Taxing Education: I happen to think that just because you throw a lot of money at a problem, it doesn’t mean that the situation improves, in short, you can (and I wouldn’t have this knowledge firsthand mind you), but shouldn’t, put a lot of dresses on a pig, or even one. It is how the money is spent that counts, which is what I was getting at last time with how the government allocates the money it collects from personal and corporate income taxes, among other sources. According to the editorial, the U of M and Minnesota’s State Colleges and Universities had a good legislative session in gaining increases of “17 and 13 percent, respectively, over the coming two years.” The reason that this is good news is that giving them tax dollars, which might be spent elsewhere, but goes instead to education, will hopefully slow the meteoric rise of college tuition.

Taxed coming or going: Sure, one way or the other, we’re paying for our education- and as the editorial reveals, and it is hard to disagree- “the rising tuition has been the result of the state’s tightfistedness toward its colleges and universities.” We either pay for it coming, by how our tax money is directed (I cite the increases from links to articles I've already referenced in previous installments on this topic) to Minnesota colleges and universities, or going, with a tuition hike if money is not directed to colleges and universities. Again, I think this true in moderation, that it depends on how those responsible for directing higher education money are spending it. If I’m making no sense so far, providing you are still reading this blog series, then prove me wrong. Otherwise, in terms of social importance, I might just barely rank ahead of the guy making balloon animals at the TGI Fridays.

Middle class exemption: The article also states things I reasonably believe to be true with a couple of caveats:

1- needy students can obtain a significant discount on tuition costs through the State Grant Program- (unfortunately, I don’t necessarily find this to be true, I didn’t receive any assistance and could have used it. If you live at home and the Grant people survey your financially struggling, divorced mother’s bank account, whose fairly limited savings is earmarked for her retirement, and find the amount of money to be “substantial,” it will get counted against you. I put myself through college- an option that won’t be possible for middle class kids in generations to come because of the rising tuition costs);

2. “the higher the share of college graduates in a state’s population, the larger the state’s median personal and household income. The higher the share of high-school graduates in a state’s population, the lower the unemployment and poverty rates.” (I have a graph in my word document but it won't paste here so I'll have to summarize what they found to be true in 2003 in regard to what level of education equates to what annual salary):

Advanced degree $72,000
Bachelor's degree $51,000
Some college $38,000
High school grad. $30,000
High school dropout $20,000

The editorial ranks the U of M, state colleges, and community colleges undergraduate programs against all other states nationally, and the average tuition in each case is higher in Minnesota than the national average; (Problem here is that costs are going up nationally. I’m not overly concerned with how specific states are doing, as the continued strain on the middle class economically is a national issue and not a regional one);

Much of the information comes from Tom Mortenson, whose report titled “Minnesota Coasting” documents the trend of rising higher education costs- the entirety of which can be found at: www.postsecondary.org including the missing graph, and the sentence: “States with better educated workforces are stronger on all measures of economic welfare.” Sure, this may be one person’s opinion or one website’s findings, but how many websites, studies, articles, percentages and dollar amounts would convince you of something that is nearly innately true? If you want to see if this site is reliable, head there in order to find the almighty percentages, the fractions, and the number of high school graduates matriculating to college;

Work it out: Republicans, who often make the point of stating that corporations won’t want to settle into a state’s economic system if corporate taxes are unfavorable, miss that the truth contained in #2 above is just as important an indicator of a state’s economic well-being. If you don’t have intelligent, skilled laborers comprising the workforce in a given state, how exactly is that corporation going to thrive? If the average republican can’t see this- then they’re probably interested in using leeches for all of their blood transfusion needs- just not the leeches and immigrants abusing the system. I thought this to be true prior to having read it elsewhere, and I just discovered it in my research for next time- in the 2000 press release link I will provide. The truth is fairly self-evident, given enough thought, and if a guy who bought into the theory that removing warts from your feet using strips of duct tape has surmised this likelihood, I must not be as dim-witted as I thought . . . or something;

If you can still deny these proofs you probably haven’t noticed the third-rate singers lip-synching terrible pop songs on The Tribute to Underdog Float at the Macy’s Thanksgiving day parade, run out of gas often, and forget the names of your own children. In short, go to the clinic and get tested- something is wrong with your mind.

Next time: More on how "necessary costs" from the private market will continue to tax (put a strain on) the middle class.

Monday, August 13, 2007

Middle Class Part 6: Where I Suspect I'm Going

I’m back. Start the insanity.

After a summer of news headlines featuring- a failed immigration bill, a wrestler committing a double-murder and suicide trifecta, Paris Hilton’s release from prison, incessant Kevin Garnett trade rumors, Michael Vick’s indictment for running a dog-fighting ring, the collapse of a well-travelled bridge, not to mention my own annual battle with sugar ants, I will withhold further comment on all of those and jump right into a Sam’s club-sized issue; this is big- the Middle class blog epic continued- part 6.

A dead horse: I’m sure that readers are coming to this site looking for something else, something more entertaining- well, not until I’ve beaten this subject to death can I will myself away. Hey, some people name their cars, some people water their lawns in the middle of the day when half of the water evaporates, and I beat dead horses. I took a Gallup poll . . . and thing is, this horse isn’t dead. There are PLENTY of, "facts", nay, “proofs” available in newspapers, online/internet articles, magazines, and books that support my points and from which one might logically make connections about the nature of the economic road ahead for future middle class citizens. Forgive me if I haven't set all of my cards out on the table quite yet . . . I'm still betting. I hate formulaic movies and books, and have a hard time writing linearly, because I like to exercise my imagination; if you love movies because the plots are familiar and books because of a certain genre- well, I'm sorry already. I'm directionally impaired and it seems that extends to the route I take to get to the crux of the matter with my blog topics. Forgive me if the subject matter this time out doesn't seem to build noticeably on what I established last time I posted. It is related, even if you can't see how at this point.

Skeptics and Revisionists: I’ve given a lot of information thus far, and I’m sure there are skeptics who question just about everything, except for their appetite for subjectivity. They continue to worship the proof not even a scientist can provide them and wouldn’t be convinced a set of Botox treatments would fill in the wrinkles on the face of a sharpie. Too many people wait for something to happen and then comment on its relative insignificance or importance- like how revisionists are stating that the gas tax should have been raised so that our roads and bridges could be improved and maintained. And, all of the money generated from the increased tax on gas would have gone to the 35W bridge. Nonsense! The trick is to be the odds maker of fortune and consider things that might happen. The economic forsaking of future generations of middle class kids by excessive taxation (a political issue) and the hefty price tags on PLENTY of products and services by businesses offering “necessary cost” items (a free market issue) will prevent the middle class from being economically able to afford a college education, because they won't be able to get married, go on a honeymoon, buy a house and a car and attend college- they won't be able to make enough money. I feel compelled to comment on this likelihood now, before it happens. If I’m wrong- wouldn’t that be great? While the middle class dilemma I see coming is hardly an "ideal" I can't wait for it to be realized before it is worthy of comment- it is worthy of comment now:

“An ideal cannot wait for its realization to prove its validity.” - George Santayana

By Degrees: I don’t want to overvalue a degree, because I have seen complete morons who have obtained one, probably through the mail, and am surprised they could work a stamp to send for it. I have also known those who have not “earned” a degree who are intelligent, and who reason more effectively than PLENTY of their “educated” counterparts. The financially leveraged college degree, or the lack of one, is almost as often a potential ticket to affluence than a demonstration of intelligence. I have a degree, but I do boneheaded things every day. A full realization of the problems facing the middle class is largely dependent on one’s class. If a person is doing fairly well, they are likely to be more apathetic or downright confrontational if you claim that things could be better, because they are hard-pressed to imagine things being better for them. I have seemed to complain a lot on behalf of successive generations of middle-class kids and their right to afford any number of things that might properly be termed- “necessary costs,” a right to an affordable college education among them. I’ve written to senators and district house representatives about immigration and the Twins stadium issue, so I don’t merely desire to fight battles with windmills, at least not exclusively. In fact, I have a strong hunch Don Quixote's antics will be considered more productive than mine.

Proposals: Below are four things I would do to begin to alleviate a money crunch that will soon overtax the coming generations of middle class kids. I’m sure you look forward to my constant diatribes at least as much as the ridding from your imaginations of the image of a giraffe spooning with an iguana slated for gender reassignment surgery, an image which wasn’t in place until just now- ha! There is some irreverence in them, but you can't get anything done if you don't upset someone's pristine notion of fairness. These are the short answer ideas, the embellishment and detail will likely come later, perhaps in various other associated blog topics, after I’ve exhausted this particular topic:

1) Find out how much of the $527 billion that is annually directed to military/defense spending is spent needlessly, and negotiate that price down; find out how much of it is earmarked for defense contractors, and how much is guaranteed to maintain the functionality of cold war weaponry that may never be used, etc.;
2) Likewise- remove the funding to the Welfare system that goes to people who abuse the system- who don’t look for jobs, who use money to support drug habits, who continue to have children, they, and society at large, cannot afford for them to have. Defense spending and money distributed to major social aid programs comprise a combined 49% of the federal budget- shouldn’t the money be spent wisely after we learn how and where money is currently directed?
3) Stop catering to the rich- the richest 1-5% of citizens and the corporations. No more corporate welfare. Change all state tax laws that make it a less attractive option for a corporation or little man with a big business idea to go to Vermont to start or grow a business than to stay put in Nebraska. That way, a business can’t hold a state, the state’s legislative and governing bodies, and worse yet, because of the potential for lost jobs, the citizens of that state, hostage by threatening to move their business. The free market won't crumble if you alter this aspect of it.
4) Pass a god-damned immigration bill! Make legal the 12+ million illegals that are already here. Many of them are doing a lot of work. Spend the money that would be saved by not hunting down every illegal on hunting down the illegals who are breaking other laws (besides being here illegally), that center around violence, drugs, gangs, irreverence, taxation, identity theft, etc. All immigrants must learn English, and cannot sue people for illegitimate reasons (more on that in the more complete version of the list). They must not prevent us from dressing our kids in Halloween costumes and sending them to school and saying “Christmas” whenever we please, (and again, I gave up being a christian for lent about 18 years ago), and they must pay taxes (which I understand plenty of them do). We could then concentrate on border control, citizen identification cards, making sure they can read traffic signs and acquire a driver's license only after demonstrating they can drive a car (I know, I'm shooting for the moon), and allow in only those who are productive, law-abiding, Americana-genuflecting immigrants. With that, and with an eye on #3 above, make it no more attractive for an illegal immigrant to settle in Minnesota, because of the welfare laws, than in Montana.

Four Limbs: I stopped at four because I think those are the most important. The other ideas aren’t all that less important, but these are just so big. Yes, yes, logistically, people would argue against undermining state’s rights, specifically where taxation is concerned, and we would have to get into the constitutionality of it all. But you have to start somewhere. It is thought that limbs once broken heal to be stronger than they were before. This country has many weak limbs in need of being broken, and coincidentally we have four limbs. Huh, ironic.

To show you that I am on the level, no anarchist, and worse yet, not a dismissively pompous republican or democrat, just someone in between who thinks that the rich should be a little more like Robin Hood and the poor not so much of a collective leech-gatherer, I give you the very quotable Winston Churchill-

“The inherent vice of capitalism is the unequal sharing of blessings; the inherent virtue of socialism is the equal sharing of miseries.”

Capitalism and Democracy: Capitalism has thus far proven to be the most effective economic system for fostering the free exchange of products, services, ideas, and money. There are some issues with it, but I can see no other economic system that has been as successful. I read Milton Friedman’s book- Capitalism and Freedom this summer. And though, he probably still knows more about economics, than I could ever hope to comprehend, and he’s been dead for nine months, I found a few faults in his line of thinking- foremost among them- that capitalism and democracy in concert, working together, are doing just fine, excepting that the rich are penalized too much for their success and the poor rewarded too often for their failure, according to him. Capitalism has been a grand success for reasons that if you have stomached reading to this point, you don’t need me to detail for you. But democracy? Yeah, riiiiiight- and there is no meaningful connection between children who spend their time at daycare and the prevalence of diagnosed cases of ear infections.

Four Score and "Soylent Green" spoiler warning: Another reason I stopped at four and decided that those four were the most imperative things to consider altering is because among them you will find that I am no republican as I desire to question outlays to the military and the filthy rich, and I am no democrat, as I would forsake the social aid/welfare people who are clearly abusing the system. I am what many people would be if they stopped continually voting for the lesser of two evils each election- sane. Yeah, I make up for that sanity by being crazy elsewhere. Sure, much of what I've written in the nine months since I started this blog is dismissed because it is combative, elusive, extremist, nonsensical and irreverent, and people think that I don't mean it, I'm just looking for shock value, like just about every other blogger out there. No, I actually think we should legitimize a third and fourth political party. I'm not being irreverent unnecessarily, but rather purposefully, with better intentions than most who continue to vote blindly like a barn full of livestock merely following the herd. I'm irreverent for a reason, but sometimes it just happens accidentally. While we are not slaves, or the proletariat in a socialist state, and we aren't served up as food like in the fairly unpredictable storyline of Charleton Heston's "Soylent Green," after we have ceased to lead productive lives, it is becoming a little more clear that the degree of liberty we enjoy is at issue. And shouldn't someone comment on this for the benefit of successive generations?

"Irreverence is the champion of Liberty"- Mark Twain

It is quite ironic, that I just this weekend heard that line in a speech given by Robin Williams playing the role of a president in "Man of the Year," a somewhat formulaic movie about a man elected to office, helped out by a computer glitch, who tells people the truth, whose irreverence for the status quo is downright respectable.

Next time- I'll take a few steps back- just wanted to show how profoundly far-reaching this topic is- that will make you long for my disgust for people who are apalled by someone putting ketchup on "their" steak.